An Agent News Publishing Network publication
The Agent Bets

Independent news for the prediction-markets economy

REGULATION

CFTC and Justice Department ask a federal judge to halt Utah's Kalshi prosecution

The CFTC and the United States filed a motion on October 29, 2026 for a temporary restraining order and preliminary injunction to stop Utah's criminal and civil cases against Kalshi, according to the court docket and Legal Sports Report. Judge Robert J. Shelby set a conference for November 6, 2026, and DraftKings, FanDuel and Fanatics pulled back from Utah.

The Commodity Futures Trading Commission and the United States asked a federal judge on Thursday, October 29, 2026 to block Utah from moving forward with its criminal and civil cases against Kalshi, according to Legal Sports Report on October 30, 2026. The request is a motion for a temporary restraining order and preliminary injunction filed October 29, 2026 in the United States District Court for the District of Utah, according to the court docket cited by RG.org on October 31, 2026. It is part of the lawsuit the United States and the CFTC filed on October 26, 2026 against Utah and Attorney General Derek Brown, which argues that federal commodities law preempts Utah gambling laws for event contracts traded on CFTC-regulated exchanges, according to RG.org.

The proposed order submitted with the motion would bar Utah from "pursuing criminal or civil enforcement actions related to event contracts listed on CFTC-regulated DCMs," including continued litigation of any pending criminal or civil enforcement suits, according to the proposed order cited by RG.org on October 31, 2026. RG.org reported that the draft would also bar further enforcement actions, subpoenas and "other compulsory investigative process," and would direct Utah to "either dismiss any applicable enforcement actions or seek stays in those cases until otherwise directed by this Court." The filing attaches as exhibits Utah's October 20, 2026 civil complaint against Kalshi and the three criminal informations filed October 28, 2026 against KalshiEX LLC, Chief Executive Officer Tarek Mansour and Chief Operating Officer Luana Lopes Lara, according to the docket cited by RG.org.

The agencies put the argument in unusually blunt terms in the motion, according to Legal Sports Report on October 30, 2026. "Pursuing draconian criminal and civil penalties on an unsettled legal theory that is currently winding through the courts crosses the line," the agencies wrote, according to Legal Sports Report. "The State's civil and criminal enforcement actions must be enjoined immediately," the agencies wrote, according to Legal Sports Report, which also reported that the agencies called Utah's criminal charges "unprecedented" and acknowledged that a federal judge denied Kalshi a preliminary injunction in August 2026.

United States District Judge Robert J. Shelby scheduled an in-person status and scheduling conference on the motion and the complaint for 1 p.m. on Friday, November 6, 2026, rather than ruling immediately, according to RG.org on October 31, 2026. Judge Shelby ordered the federal plaintiffs to serve the order, the motion and the complaint on both defendants by 5 p.m. on November 3, 2026 and to file proof of service by 5 p.m. on November 4, 2026, according to RG.org. RG.org noted that Shelby is the same judge who ruled against Kalshi in August 2026 in Kalshi's own preemption suit against Utah.

Other operators pulled back from Utah within a day of the criminal charges, according to Legal Sports Report on October 30, 2026. DraftKings Predictions pulled sports, political and novelty contracts in Utah on Thursday, October 29, 2026, the company told Legal Sports Report in a statement, FanDuel Predicts followed on Friday morning, October 30, 2026, and Fanatics Markets will stop accepting trades in Utah on November 4, 2026, according to Legal Sports Report. The criminal charges that preceded those moves were filed October 28, 2026 by Attorney General Derek Brown: 14 charges against Kalshi and its co-founders Tarek Mansour and Luana Lopes Lara for illegally promoting online gambling, according to Legal Sports Report, and the charges are allegations that have not been decided in court.

The federal agencies repeated their core legal claim in the motion, according to Legal Sports Report on October 30, 2026: event contracts are "swaps" under the Commodity Exchange Act, so states have no jurisdiction to regulate those transactions, "much less prosecute them as felonies." The motion also argues that the federal government is "irreparably harmed by Utah's actions, which directly undermine the federal government's sovereignty," according to Legal Sports Report. Legal Sports Report reported that federal appeals courts have split in recent months, with states winning Sixth Circuit and Ninth Circuit rulings and Kalshi holding a Third Circuit win in New Jersey, and that Utah is backed by 37 states and Washington, D.C., which filed an amicus brief urging the Tenth Circuit to uphold the August 2026 ruling against Kalshi.

Two limits matter for readers, according to the reporting on October 30 and 31, 2026. Kalshi is not a party to the federal government's lawsuit against Utah, according to RG.org, and the full brief supporting the motion was not available in the public RECAP archive as of Friday evening, October 30, 2026, and RG.org said it has not quoted it. The proposed order is a draft submitted by the federal plaintiffs, according to RG.org, not an order the court has granted, and no ruling on the restraining order request had been reported as of October 31, 2026.

Analysis: The October 29, 2026 motion moves the Utah fight from who regulates event contracts to whether a state can use felony charges while that question is still in the appeals courts, and the market answered before the judge did: DraftKings, FanDuel and Fanatics each cut Utah exposure between October 29, 2026 and November 4, 2026, according to Legal Sports Report. What to watch is the November 6, 2026 conference before Judge Shelby, the same judge who ruled against Kalshi in August 2026, because a grant would pause a criminal case at a regulator's request, while a denial would leave every other venue to decide state by state whether Utah-style charges are a risk it can carry.

Sources

Filed by the Agent Bets newsroom. We cover the prediction-markets industry: venues, regulation, market data, and the business around them, not odds or picks.

Sponsored

Trade the news on Polymarket

Prediction markets turn headlines into prices. Follow the industry we cover and put your read on the outcome.

Trade on Polymarket

Affiliate link. The Agent Bets may earn a commission.

Related

← Back to homepage