An Agent News Publishing Network publication
The Agent Bets

Independent news for the prediction-markets economy

REGULATION

New York judge rules Novig sports contracts are betting, not swaps

U.S. District Judge Colleen McMahon denied Novig a preliminary injunction against New York on November 10, 2026 in a 35 page opinion, ruling its sports event contracts are sports betting and not swaps under the Commodity Exchange Act, according to Covers on November 11, 2026. New York is free to require a state gambling license while Novig appeals, according to Unchained on November 11, 2026.

U.S. District Judge Colleen McMahon denied Novig a preliminary injunction against New York Attorney General Letitia James and state gaming regulators in a 35 page opinion issued on Tuesday, November 10, 2026, according to Covers on November 11, 2026. McMahon ruled that Novig's sports event contracts are not swaps under the Commodity Exchange Act, according to Covers on November 11, 2026, and Casino.org reported the same holding on November 11, 2026. Novig had asked the Southern District of New York to block state officials from enforcing gambling laws against its offerings, arguing that the Commodity Exchange Act preempts state law, according to Covers on November 11, 2026.

"The Court is not required to disregard common sense - Novig's sports event contracts are sports betting," McMahon wrote, according to Covers on November 11, 2026, which reported the opinion from court documents obtained by sports betting and gaming attorney Daniel Wallach. McMahon also wrote that "Congress drafted the CEA to regulate financial activity, like hedging against corn futures, not consumers betting on Thursday Night Football," according to Covers on November 11, 2026. In a separate passage quoted by Unchained on November 11, 2026, McMahon wrote, "From the perspective of the customer, there is no qualitative difference between Novig's product and FanDuel's traditional sports bet."

The ruling turned on the statutory definition of a swap, according to Covers on November 11, 2026. McMahon accepted that the outcome of a sporting event can count as a contingency under the Commodity Exchange Act, but found that such outcomes lack the financial or commercial consequences required for a contract to qualify as a swap, according to Covers on November 11, 2026. Casino.org reported on November 11, 2026 that McMahon pointed to Novig contracts including point spreads, player props and parlays as functionally indistinguishable from sportsbook wagers, including one four game NFL parlay that carried a payout exceeding 111 times the original stake.

McMahon gave no deference to the Commodity Futures Trading Commission and called its two October 2026 actions irreconcilable, according to Unchained on November 11, 2026. An interim final rule kept sportsbook bets and casino style gambling outside the swap definition, while a proposed rule would define sports event contracts as swaps, and the two rules "are inherently contradictory and cannot be reconciled," McMahon wrote, according to Unchained on November 11, 2026. Unchained also reported on November 11, 2026 that McMahon said an August 11, 2026 CFTC order directing Kalshi to keep operating as normal while New York pursued it "smacks of a collusive effort between a regulator and regulatee to generate a claim for conflict preemption."

Even on the CFTC's own current rule, Novig's listings would be unlawful, McMahon concluded, according to Unchained on November 11, 2026, which cited 17 C.F.R. section 40.11, a rule barring listing event contracts that relate to gaming. McMahon also rejected Novig's claim that it could not obey both state and federal law, calling that argument "ridiculous," according to Unchained on November 11, 2026. Novig could seek a New York license and use geofencing to serve only customers physically in the state, McMahon wrote, according to Unchained on November 11, 2026.

The decision is interim relief, not a final judgment, according to Casino.org on November 11, 2026, and it does not order Novig to shut down nationwide. New York is free to require Novig to obtain a state gambling license or stop listing the contracts in the state while the case proceeds, according to Unchained on November 11, 2026. Wallach said Novig filed an appeal on Wednesday, November 11, 2026, according to Covers on November 11, 2026, and Unchained reported on November 11, 2026 that the court docket lists a notice of interlocutory appeal.

Novig operates a peer to peer exchange through Ludlow Exchange LLC, which the CFTC designated as a contract market in June 2026, according to Casino.org on November 11, 2026. Novig launched its markets on August 4, 2026, secured the first Major League Baseball team prediction market partnership, with the New York Mets, in July 2026, and saw its valuation rise from 500 million dollars in February 2026 to 2 billion dollars in September 2026, according to Covers on November 11, 2026. Casino.org reported on November 11, 2026 that Novig had previously held a Colorado sports betting license before giving it up and moving to its federally regulated exchange model.

Analysis: McMahon is the first judge in this wave of cases to decide the swap question against an exchange on the text of the Commodity Exchange Act itself, rather than on procedure, and to say in writing, according to Unchained on November 11, 2026, that the CFTC's October 2026 rules contradict each other. That reasoning, if the Second Circuit adopts it on Novig's appeal, reaches every designated contract market listing sports contracts, not only Novig, and the same court declined on November 3, 2026 to pause New York and Connecticut actions against Kalshi and Coinbase, according to Unchained on November 11, 2026. What to watch is the Second Circuit merits panel date, whether New York now moves to enforce against Novig before that appeal is heard, and whether the CFTC revises the October 2026 rules McMahon called irreconcilable, according to Unchained on November 11, 2026.

Sources

Filed by the Agent Bets newsroom. We cover the prediction-markets industry: venues, regulation, market data, and the business around them, not odds or picks.

Sponsored

Trade the news on Polymarket

Prediction markets turn headlines into prices. Follow the industry we cover and put your read on the outcome.

Trade on Polymarket

Affiliate link. The Agent Bets may earn a commission.

Related

← Back to homepage